News
Lessons learnt: Why sharing could save lives Richard Dolman
Lessons Learned: Why Sharing Our Experiences Could Save Lives By Richard Dolman MSc FIDE, Former President of the Institute of Demolition Engineers Richard Dolman is a former President of the Institute of Demolition…
Lessons Learned: Why Sharing Our Experiences Could Save Lives
By Richard Dolman MSc FIDE, Former President of the Institute of Demolition Engineers
Richard Dolman is a former President of the Institute of Demolition Engineers and has long advocated professional openness, technical knowledge-sharing, and learning from experience.
The demolition industry has an extraordinary depth of experience and technical expertise. Yet some of our most valuable lessons remain hidden, often because we are reluctant to discuss what has gone wrong. Former IDE President Richard Dolman explains why he made Lessons Learned a personal priority, the experiences that shaped his thinking, and why he believes openness, honesty, and professional collaboration are essential to our industry's future.
Every Incident Has a Lesson - But Only If We Share It
Throughout my career in demolition, I have always believed that experience is one of the most valuable assets we possess. We work in a challenging industry where every structure presents different risks, every project requires careful consideration, and the consequences of getting things wrong can be severe.
Yet something has troubled me for many years. As an industry, we are very good at discussing our successes, achievements and the impressive projects we undertake. We are far less comfortable discussing the occasions when things have not gone according to plan, and that is precisely where some of our most important learning opportunities lie.
Every contractor, consultant and demolition engineer will, at some point in their career, have experienced a situation in which something unexpected happened or where the outcome could have been significantly worse.
The important question is not simply what happened, but what we learned and how we can prevent someone else from experiencing the same thing.
That question became particularly important to me during my tenure as President of the Institute of Demolition Engineers. However, my commitment to sharing Lessons Learned began considerably earlier.
The Incident That Changed My Thinking
My journey towards promoting Lessons Learned began around 2010–2011, following a demolition project on a Space Deck roof structure in Bristol.
We recognised from the outset that there was a risk of structural collapse, and our demolition methodology was developed around that risk.
During the works, the roof collapsed. Although the possibility had been anticipated, witnessing the event brought home just how serious the consequences could have been had the work not been properly planned.
I subsequently presented the project at an IDE seminar to explain what had happened, the rationale behind our methodology and the lessons other demolition engineers could draw from the experience.
What was particularly interesting was the initial reaction.
Before I had the opportunity to explain the circumstances, the incident had already been discussed by others in a way that suggested it had simply gone wrong through incompetence, when in fact the reality was very different. The risk had been identified, and the methodology had been developed with that possibility in mind.
It reinforced something I have believed ever since: we should never judge an incident without understanding the circumstances, the engineering decisions and the lessons to be drawn from it.
But something even more positive happened afterwards: after my presentation, someone from Network Rail contacted me, having seen the information and recognised similarities with a Space Deck roof at King's Cross Station in London.
That contact ultimately led to my involvement in the King's Cross project in 2012.
For me, this demonstrated something especially important.
By being prepared to share an experience others might have preferred to keep quiet, I had helped another organisation understand a potentially significant structural risk. At the same time, that openness had led to a positive commercial opportunity.
Sharing Lessons Learned was not a sign of weakness; it was a demonstration of professional competence, integrity and experience.
The Fire Extinguisher Incident: What We Don't Know Can Hurt Us
A further experience reinforced my thinking.
During operations at a quarry, an item of demolition debris contained a CO₂ fire extinguisher. As an excavator was sorting through the material, the extinguisher ruptured violently; it split apart, and part of it was propelled with sufficient force to travel over a substantial building, approximately 90 metres.
Fortunately, the consequences were not as serious as they might have been. Nevertheless, it was an alarming demonstration of the stored energy in a pressurised cylinder and of the danger when such items mix with demolition debris.
When we researched the incident, we found surprisingly little readily available information on similar incidents.
I decided to share what had happened at an IDE event. After the presentation, several people approached me to say they had experienced similar incidents. I remember thinking: here we are, with several professionals in the same room who have experienced the same dangerous event, yet none of us knew about each other's experiences; how many more incidents had occurred elsewhere?
How many contractors were unknowingly exposing their employees to a hazard that others had already encountered?
And perhaps most importantly, how many future incidents could be prevented if that information were freely available?
That experience strengthened my conviction that we simply had to become better at sharing information.
It should not take a serious injury or fatality for the industry to recognise a hazard that others have already experienced.
Learning From Other Industries
During this period, I also read Black Box Thinking by Matthew Syed, a book that examines how different industries respond to mistakes, failures and unexpected outcomes.
One of the most important lessons I took from it was the approach to sharing safety information within aviation.
In aviation, there is recognition that information about failures, defects, and potentially catastrophic incidents has value well beyond the organisation in which they occur. Even commercial competitors have a common interest in preventing failures that might threaten lives.
That approach struck me as something the demolition industry should aspire to.
We operate in an environment where structural instability, heavy machinery, temporary works, hazardous materials and complex demolition sequences can all present significant risks.
If one contractor discovers something that could prevent a serious incident on another contractor's site, why should that information remain confidential purely for commercial reasons?
Competition is an important part of business, but safety should not become a competitive secret.
We should be competing on competence, innovation, professionalism and the quality of our work, rather than on how well we conceal our mistakes.
Changing the Culture: Openness Should Be Rewarded, Not Punished
One of the greatest barriers to sharing Lessons Learned is the fear of reputational damage.
There remains a perception that admitting that something has gone wrong is an admission of incompetence.
Contractors may worry about losing future work, damaging client relationships or giving competitors an opportunity to criticise their business.
I believe we need to turn that thinking on its head.
A company that experiences a problem, investigates it properly, identifies the causes, improves its procedures, and then shares those findings has demonstrated something extremely valuable.
It has demonstrated that it is capable of learning.
It has demonstrated that it takes its responsibilities seriously.
And it has shown that it is prepared to contribute to improving safety beyond its own organisation.
This should all be recognised as a positive professional characteristic.
The alternative is a culture in which people are reluctant to speak openly, incidents are discussed in private, and valuable information never reaches those who need it.
We all make mistakes, and we all encounter unforeseen circumstances; what matters is how we respond.
We should never make people feel ashamed of sharing what went wrong when their intention is to prevent it happening again.
Of course, openness does not remove the need for accountability. Poor decisions and failures to manage foreseeable risks must still be addressed.
However, accountability and learning should complement one another, not become reasons for suppressing information.
Why Lessons Learned Became Important During My IDE Presidency
When I became President of the IDE, I recognised that the Institute was uniquely placed to promote a more open approach to professional learning.
The IDE brings together demolition engineers, contractors, consultants and other specialists who collectively possess an enormous amount of knowledge and experience.
That knowledge should be one of the profession's greatest resources.
But knowledge is only valuable if it is shared, understood and applied.
I wanted Lessons Learned to become a positive, recognised part of the Institute's work, rather than something discussed only after a major incident.
The objective was never to embarrass individuals or organisations. It was to encourage the profession to learn from real experiences, including those in which the outcome had not been as originally intended.
I have spoken openly about incidents involving structural demolition, equipment operating on suspended slabs, and the risks associated with certain demolition methods.
In my experience, being prepared to stand up and discuss these issues has led to positive results.
People have approached me afterwards, shared their own experiences and, in some cases, used that information to reconsider how they planned similar activities.
That is what the Institute should encourage.
An IDE seminar should be a place where members feel comfortable sharing not only their most impressive projects but also the difficult experiences that have made them better engineers.
Recognising Dangerous Practices Before They Become Normal
One issue I have been particularly vocal about is the relationship between high-reach demolition operations and scaffolding positioned close to structures undergoing demolition.
Where scaffolding is used to reduce exclusion zones or to provide protection during high-reach operations, we must be absolutely certain that we have not introduced a greater hazard than the one we were trying to control.
Repeated incidents should prompt us to question whether a particular approach is appropriate.
Yet too often we see potentially dangerous practices repeated, sometimes because they appear commercially attractive or because they have become accepted as normal practice.
That is why sharing information about incidents is so important.
If an incident in London highlights a problem with a specific demolition arrangement, engineers in Australia, America or elsewhere should be able to learn from it.
Equally, an incident overseas may contain vital information relevant to a demolition project in the United Kingdom.
We should not allow geographical boundaries, commercial competition or organisational reluctance to prevent that knowledge from reaching the people who need it.
As the IDE continues to strengthen its international connections, there is an opportunity to cultivate a genuinely global culture of shared learning.
Reporting an Incident Is Only the Beginning
Another important distinction, which I believe we sometimes overlook, is that reporting an incident and learning from it are not necessarily the same thing.
An organisation may investigate an event, prepare a detailed report, identify contributing factors and develop recommendations.
But if those findings remain within the organisation, their wider value is lost.
I have been encouraged by the work of organisations such as CROSS, which offer opportunities for confidential reporting and professional review of safety concerns.
However, the essential part of any reporting system is ensuring that the information ultimately reaches those working in the industry.
It is pointless reporting an incident if the lessons never reach those who could benefit from them.
We need a continuous process in which incidents are reported, technical information is reviewed, lessons are identified, and those lessons are actively communicated.
Most importantly, we need evidence that the learning has been put into practice.
It is not enough to have a collection of incident reports that no one reads.
Creating an Environment Where People Want to Share
I recognise that changing attitudes will not happen overnight.
Some people are still uncomfortable discussing incidents publicly, particularly when their own organisation has been involved.
One approach may be to implement a two-stage process.
Initially, an incident could be submitted confidentially, with identifying details removed where appropriate, so the technical circumstances and lessons could be reviewed and shared.
Where those involved are comfortable, the next stage could involve presenting the experience openly at an Institute event or in a published case study.
Not everyone will want to stand on stage and discuss a difficult incident.
But everyone should have the opportunity to contribute to our profession's collective knowledge.
I also believe the Institute has a responsibility to recognise and actively promote those who are willing to share.
If members see other professionals being respected and applauded for their openness rather than criticised, we may begin to change the culture.
Over time, sharing Lessons Learned should become a normalised and routine part of professional practice.
Building on the Work for the Future
I am pleased that the Institute continues to develop the Lessons Learned initiative and has introduced a dedicated area on its website to encourage members to contribute.
This is an important opportunity to build on work that began for me more than fifteen years ago.
But a website alone will not change our industry.
We need members to engage with it.
We need contractors and consultants to submit examples of incidents, near misses and successful innovations.
We need experienced demolition engineers to discuss the decisions they have made, the problems they have encountered, and what they might do differently in future.
We need our seminars, technical meetings and publications to provide opportunities for those conversations to take place.
And we need to ensure that the lessons are translated into better engineering decisions, safer methodologies and improved working practices.
This cannot be the responsibility of a single President, a single committee or a single individual.
It must become part of the professional culture of the Institute and of the wider demolition industry.
A Final Thought: The Most Valuable Lesson May Be the One You Share
Looking back, some of the most positive developments in my career have stemmed from situations that, at the time, were difficult or unexpected.
The Bristol Space Deck roof project, the fire extinguisher incident and other experiences taught me that sharing what happened could benefit people far beyond my own organisation.
Those experiences shaped my approach to Lessons Learned and became an important part of what I sought to promote as President of the IDE.
I remain convinced that we have a tremendous opportunity to improve our industry by being more open about our experiences.
We should celebrate successful projects, but we should also recognise the value of understanding what happens when things do not go to plan.
Professionalism is not about pretending that nothing ever goes wrong.
It is about recognising risk, responding responsibly, continually improving, and being prepared to help others benefit from what we have learnt.
If sharing one experience prevents another demolition engineer from making the same mistake, avoids a serious injury, or saves someone's life, then that experience was worth sharing.
That is why Lessons Learned has always mattered so much to me, and that is why I hope the Institute will continue to champion it for many years to come.
Share Your Lessons Learned With the IDE
The Institute of Demolition Engineers encourages members and industry professionals to share their experiences, including incidents, near misses, engineering challenges and examples of good practice.
Contributions can help identify recurring hazards, improve demolition methodologies and support the continued development of professional knowledge.
Whether you wish to share an experience openly or submit information anonymously, your contribution could make a genuine difference.
Visit the Lessons Learned section of the IDE website (https://ide.org.uk/guidance/lessons-learned) and help make our industry safer through shared knowledge.